Consultant vs Agency

November 10, 2026

How to manage your ecommerce agencies: a founder's guide

Short answer: give every agency the same commercial target, judge them on your own numbers rather than their reports, and have someone senior on your side who meets them every week and makes the calls they need. Most agency problems are management problems.

Signs your agencies aren't being managed

  • Each agency reports on its own channel, in its own terms, and every report looks good
  • Added together, the agencies claim more revenue than the business made
  • Nobody has asked an agency a hard question in months
  • Ads point at products that are out of stock in most sizes
  • The founder spends hours a week in reporting calls

1. Set one commercial target

Paid, email and SEO should all work to the same number, usually revenue at a target cost of sale, or new customers at a target cost. When each agency picks its own measure, each one can hit it while the business misses.

2. Brief properly, every season

A good brief covers the trading calendar, the products to push and why, the stock position, the budget and the target. Agencies fill gaps in a brief with whatever is easiest, so leave fewer gaps.

3. Judge them on your numbers

Use Shopify and GA4 as the source of truth, not each platform's own attribution. Look at total revenue, cost of sale and new customers across all channels together, then ask each agency how their work moved those numbers.

4. Run a weekly rhythm

  • Weekly: a short call per agency on last week's numbers, this week's priorities and any decisions they need
  • Monthly: spend against results by channel, and what changes next month
  • Quarterly: a proper review of each agency against the target, including whether the scope and fee still make sense

5. Connect the agencies to the trading

Agencies can't see your stock, your margins or what the buying team has coming. Someone has to tell them which products have sizes to sell, what's being cleared and what lands next month. Without that, spend drifts to whatever converted last week.

6. Check the work independently now and then

An audit of the ad accounts and tracking once or twice a year, by someone who doesn't run them, catches wasted spend and tracking gaps the agency has no reason to point out.

Who should do this?

Someone senior enough to challenge an agency and make decisions on the spot. In many growing brands that's the founder by default, squeezed in around everything else. A fractional Head of Ecommerce takes it on one day a week, so the founder gets the time back and the agencies get clear direction.

The short version

One target for every agency, a proper brief each season, your numbers not theirs, a weekly rhythm, and someone senior who links the agencies to the trading. Agencies work best with a client who knows exactly what to ask for.

Where ETTA can help

Ecommerce Leadership and Agency Management

A senior head of ecommerce one day a week, a roadmap everyone works to, and agencies held to profit rather than activity.

Read about this service →